Michael J. Totten: Liberal Versus Liberal

November 09, 2003

Liberal Versus Liberal

Andrew Hagan has a good solution to the battle between liberal hawks and the anti-warriors over who gets to call themselves "liberal."

It's a fine solution, and I'm surprised I haven't seen this before.

Simply divide the liberals into camps. The right has already done this to itself.

There are paleoconservatives of the inflexible old-fashioned Pat Buchanan variety. And there are neoconservatives who are more moderate and who often have a left-wing pedigree. There are also just plain old conservative conservatives.

So why not carve up the left the same way? There are paleoliberals and there are neoliberals. The neolibs have already been identified; they're the moderate (and often hated) brainy folks at The New Republic. But the paleolibs are thus far unnamed and unexamined. They aren't radical leftists, but they are out of date and rather inflexible. Andrew Hagan, a moderate liberal himself, has their number.

UPDATE: Matt Welch in the comments asked a good question, and I see I forgot to include something obvious. There also are plain old liberal liberals, like Matthew Yglesias and Kevin Drum, who don't need a paleo or neo attached. They aren't reactionary, as the paleoliberals are, and I never get into arguments with either of them about who is a "real" liberal and who is a heretic.

Posted by Michael J. Totten at November 9, 2003 05:50 PM

Comments

In which category would you classify Matthew Yglesias and Kevin Drum?

Posted by: Matt Welch at November 9, 2003 06:02 PM

Ow! That's going to leave a mark...

Posted by: Mike Spenis at November 9, 2003 06:20 PM

Matt: In which category would you classify Matthew Yglesias and Kevin Drum?

I would put them in the just plain old liberal category, without a prefix, just as George W. Bush is a plain old conservative without a neo- or paleo- attached.

Posted by: Michael J. Totten at November 9, 2003 06:28 PM

Okay...that we're identifying the difference is a good thing but I'm a little offended by the phrasing "paleo". Granted, their pacifism is very much akin to Pat Buchanan sytle "paleoconservative" isolationism. But Buchanan's paleo-conservativism harks back to the time of Woodrow Wilson and Henry Cabot Lodge. Neo-liberalism, as it is called, in terms of dates is really more "paleo" than the current strain of post-Vietnam pussyleftism...it's the liberalism of Wilson, FDR, Truman, and Kennedy. Clinton, to his credit, realized that the ghosts of Vietnam needed to be desperately purged from the Democratic Party and sought to revive the Wilsonian foreign policy of the Cold War Democrats by calling it new or "neo" to put a "don't stop thinking about tomorrow" spin on it. I wrote a 20-page paper on this. Trust me, I know what I'm talking about. Funny that Bush has taken up the Wilsonian charge though, isn't it? At least someone has.

Posted by: Grant McEntire at November 9, 2003 06:35 PM

I shouldn't have coined the term "pussyleftism" just then. That was inappropriate. I apologize.

Posted by: Grant McEntire at November 9, 2003 06:38 PM

Grant,

"Paleo" just means old. It's true that liberal hawks have older left-wing foreign policy ideas. But it's also the case that the self-described neoliberals, like those at The New Republic, are what you might call "reconstructed" liberals who have moved away from the excesses of the 1960s New Left. Neoliberals think of themselves, quite rightly, as people with left-of-center ideas that are updated to fit modern realities. The paleoliberals, in Andrew Hagan's formulation, are stuck at a specific point in the past.

Posted by: Michael J. Totten at November 9, 2003 06:47 PM

Paleoliberals aren't radical leftists, according to Michael. And yet Hagan says that they would toss most of our cherished values down the toilet, and replace our society with a different one, without feeling the need to give a justification. These ideals seem more Leninist than American to me.

Paleos on both right and left represent positions that are not worth debating, being of zero plausibility. The plain-old liberals and plain-old conservatives represent positions that everyone knows have seemingly insurmountable difficulties, but are yet somewhat plausible. The neos of both kinds have nailed it and are arguing over which of the two darts is in the exact center of the bull's eye. They ought to account for most of the members of Congress. That they don't is depressing.

Posted by: Jim at November 9, 2003 08:02 PM

Jim: The neos of both kinds have nailed it and are arguing over which of the two darts is in the exact center of the bull's eye.

Yeah, I think that's pretty much right. There are differences between the two, and I definitely prefer the neoliberals to the neoconservatives. But these days I can do business with both.

Posted by: Michael J. Totten at November 9, 2003 08:18 PM

"We shall not be moved
We shall not be moved
Just like a tree standing by the water side
Oh, We shall not be moved"

Repeat, repeat, repeat, repeat.

Hey guys, the war's over.

Repeat, repeat, repeat, repeat.

Hey guys, we aren't fighting the communists anymore!

These people are just living up to the lyrics they have chanted for decades, and they don't care that situations have changed. Repeat, repeat, repeat...

Posted by: Patrick Lasswell at November 9, 2003 09:03 PM

tottensimons?

Posted by: ooh ooh at November 9, 2003 09:18 PM

I'm sure a lot of paleoliberals will vigorously deny that they are paleoliberals. I'm not attempting to make a pseudo-sociological classification. Admittedly, finding a single person that fits every criteria I laid out would be difficult. By paleoliberals, I meant to describe a wide swathe of people.

MJT has characteristically nailed it with regard to plain old liberals. You'd see a lot more plain-old liberal bloggers than you would in real life, because blogging forces you to think. Most of the Democratic Party candidates are paleoliberals, or are currently campaigning like them. This indicates they believe a lot of opinionmakers agree with their positions and rhetoric.

I said that "they would toss most of our cherished values down the toilet?" No, I never said that. I would say that they want to change our society from top to bottom, and that they do not share basic American values, such as showing reverence at funeral services. They do not intend to toss out our values for us. They intend to undermine them.

Posted by: Andrew Hagen at November 9, 2003 09:28 PM

Michael,

Why coin a neologism for what seems to be a return to classical liberalism? Is there some aspect of classical liberalism that those who you would classify as neolibs reject? Are the paleolib's really liberals or are they syncretic heretics? (I'd vote for the latter - but I'm not a liberal.) After all, at the completion of a revolution, you're right where you started.

Posted by: RDB at November 9, 2003 11:14 PM

RDB: Is there some aspect of classical liberalism that those who you would classify as neolibs reject?

No. I suppose you could say neoliberals are left-of-center classical liberals. A neoliberal probably agrees that we need some kind of universal health coverage, but would like it not to be statist.

I wrote about something like that here.

Posted by: Michael J. Totten at November 9, 2003 11:45 PM

Michael, to add to your response to RDB, "neoliberalism" has been around as a concept for at least two decades, and it's not the same as classical liberalism (which is now right-wing libertarianism). Neoliberalism is simply a pragmatic implementation of the liberal program which is decoupled from orthodox values and excessive partisanship. (I say this as a libertarian-conservative, so take my commentary with a grain of salt.)

In international politics, neoliberals are hawkish and reject the pacifist norm of the left, because they have no patience for the notion that every hostile regime can be "reasoned with" given enough time. In domestic politics, neoliberals are Democrats who sometimes cross over to support Republicans, because they believe that policies are to be judged for their utility rather than how closely they align with liberal articles of faith.

Posted by: Matthew Stinson at November 10, 2003 02:18 AM

A neoliberal probably agrees that we need some kind of universal health coverage, but would like it not to be statist.

Contradiction in terms. "Universal" coverage will always be founded on some kind of mandate from the state, and will always have to have some kind of "safety net" for people who can't or won't buy insurance for themselves, otherwise it won't be universal.

By definition, then, universal coverage is statist at its core. A classical liberal (what we now call libertarians) would not think that it was any of the state's business how she chose to pay for her health care, and would object to being required by law to both choose a particular method (insurance) and to pay for someone else's care (via the safety net).

Universal coverage is fundamentally socialist, not "classical liberal," because it brings a bif chunk of the economy under state direction. This isn't necessarily to dismiss it, just trying to keep the taxonomy straight.

Posted by: R C Dean at November 10, 2003 04:10 AM

Another way to divide the elephant: neoconservatives and neoliberals are more open to innovation and change than their plain-vanilla conservative and liberal brethren. Thus neo-cons will support gay marriage (or at least domestic partnership) and neo-libs are willing to substantially revisit thie assumptions about U.S. security position and its integration into the internationalist framework in the wake of 9/11.

To me, at least, the plain-vanilla variety is somewhat more "conservative" in that they want to defend the existing positions of their respective camps. There are many such distinctions, from positions on affirmative action and school vouchers to laws regarding changing social mores. Liberal hawks, South Park Republicans--these are really names for the emerging neo-branches of each strain.

Since I'm basically an optimist regarding the U.S.'s ability to accept and incorporate ongoing and substantial change, I tend to find the neo-cons and neo-libs more interesting and intellectually dynamic than their plain-vanilla counterparts. This is why Bush's "radical" speech positioning the U.S. on the right side of the drive toward democratization of the Middle East is very exciting to both the neos- but less warmly received by the plain-vanillas in both camps.

Posted by: Daniel Calto at November 10, 2003 07:18 AM

There have been some very sharp assessments made in this comment thread (and on the whole the tripartite division of liberal and conservative camps strikes me, cursorily, as a very helpful albeit somewhat rigid classificatory framework) - I love the image of the neocons and neolibs arguing over which dart is closer to the bullseye. I would particularly like to second Daniel Calto's 'division of the elephant' above, about how the neos on either side are more willing to entertain radical CHANGE (not 'radical left' or 'radical right' ideas, but the thing itself: the Greek Delta) than their more staid brethren. There may be an element of self-regard in this 'radical' center's appreciation of their own willingness to try outside-the-box solutions, but there's truth there nonetheless.

Neocons and neolibs, if that's what they are to be called, are becoming increasingly impatient with the same-old non-solution solutions and fatuous pieties offered by ideologues of either side, while also recognizing much merit in their adopted basic liberal or conservative outlooks. So you get the crossover effect: from global terrorism (liberals forsaking old-fashioned pacifism, conservatives reclaiming previously unRepublican idealist views on spreading liberty abroad) to gay rights or abortion (the blur here revolves around an essentially libertarian/moral axis, as the neocons from the right move towards a live-and-let-live view of gay marriage and the neolibs towards an understanding of the human cost of abortion), a new zone of consensus is being forged as we speak.

The interesting thing about this is that despite the ideological sympathies of neolibs for neocons - their ability to 'do business with each other' as Michael Totten would say - there will always be fundamental divisions between them that will ensure their remaining apart from one another; not just differences in temperament but in substance as well. I think this is actually a very good thing, as I prefer the constructive intellectual friction that such essentially 'loyal' opposition generates. It's far preferable to stultifying unity and suffocating consensus.

Posted by: Jeff B. at November 10, 2003 12:20 PM

RC Dean: keeping taxonomy straight on health care is pretty difficult. In your view, it would seem our current health care system is "fundamentally socialist", since it is driven by tax breaks to employers, plus Medicare and Medicaid.

Daniel: very well-put.

Posted by: Oberon at November 10, 2003 12:26 PM

I take it your talking about more recent definitions of the terms "neoconservative" and "neoliberal". Almost to a man, neoliberals in the '80's, such as Gary Hart, were much more dovish than the average Democrat, whereas "neoconservatives" at that time (ie., Podheretz, Peretz, Kristol, et al.) were distinguished by their hostility to civil rights and feminism, as well as a hawkish foreign policy. I suspect that even today most self-described neoliberals are opposed to the Bush policy (such as it is) in Iraq, and are more likely to depart from liberal orthodoxy on issues like vouchers and affirmative action. Neoconservatives (or the more accurate term, chicken hawks), on the other hand, are now pushing an extremely idealistic foreign policy, one not constrained by issues of practicality or truthfulness (or even patriotism, as the Valerie Plame affair showed).

Posted by: Steve Smith at November 10, 2003 12:40 PM

Well, then sign me up for neoconservative foreign policy. In fact, however, I don't see anything inconsistent with a strong foreign policy and either liberalism or neoliberalism.

Steve Smith, your characterization of the (current) foreign policy as impractical and untruthful are the opposite of the truth.

What we saw on 9/11 was that the old policy was a failure. We were not encouraging democracy enough. We were not improving the lot of the world's poor enough. We were not exercising hegemony in a fundamentally just manner. This manner may have been relaxed, allowing Saddams and Burmese regimes to exist into perpetuity, but it was nevertheless negligent.

We had to change or face the prospect of a loss of hegemony not only for the USA but also for liberal democracy. To have kept the old, paleoliberal approach, as with Steve Smith apparently, would have been to enter into a suicide pact. Change or die.

It is far more practical, honest, and strategic to effect preventative change before the poison has fully taken effect. In that case, the first and most important job is taking out foreign brutes.

For the paleoliberals, none of this can be true. There is no evil. All we need to do is to smoke some dope with Osama and all will be right between us. Welcome back from fantasyland.

Posted by: Andrew Hagen at November 10, 2003 12:58 PM

Daniel and Jeff B. mention the distinction between the looney changes advocated by radicals and the openness to change that characterizes the neos at the center. The former is dogma-driven, while the latter is driven by devotion to evidence and getting things right. The former won't change the agenda under any circumstances. The latter is conservatively resistant to change only as long as the evidence supports this attitude. (I'm a neo-con. A neo-lib might write that last sentence: "The latter is open to change as long as the evidence doesn't count against it.")

Both Steve Smith and Jeff B. point to substantial rifts between the center neos. These rifts are usually owing to differences between their genuine efforts to evaluate the arguments and evidence. The paleos left and right, on the other hand, do not deliberate in good faith. They are simply authoritarians. Meanwhile the plain-olds, left and right, are somewhat open to the evidence against their views, but not enough so.

As Socrates would have said, devotion to the truth is pivotal.

Posted by: Jim at November 10, 2003 01:11 PM

The concept that neoconservative foreign policy involves a devotion to the truth is absurd to me. It has been made clear that a devotion to wishful thinking and a disregard for the possibility of nonoptimal outcomes is a hallmark of the neoconservative approach.

Posted by: Kimmitt at November 10, 2003 01:59 PM

Jim: Well put. Socrates was right.

Apart from devotion to the truth as opposed to devotion to one's ideological position (evidence be damned), I think the neo-cons and neo-libs can also be characterized as more comfortable with ambiguity, being more willing to act upon imperfect but substantial evidence, more willing to tolerate paradox, and understanding at times that the perfect is the enemy of the good. This is one reason neo-cons and neo-libs can work together in support of the same policy (for different reasons) and not lose sleep over it.
This obviously does not characterize the paleos.

Posted by: Daniel Calto at November 10, 2003 02:06 PM

To Andrew Hagen

Tbogg's outed you dumbass. You might as well quit lying. Quote "I hold left-wing views. As an
American, I'm a political independent who leans toward the Democratic Party and away from the Green Party." Please don't lean toward the Democratic party. We don't want your worthless, lying ass. Go back and join your freeper friends.
P.S. Time to get off the Oxycotin dittohead now that they got your dealer Limbaugh in a padded cell where he belongs.

Posted by: Phonyliberals at November 11, 2003 09:19 AM

I must say that Andrew's screed is the lamest, ill thought piece of crap I have ever read on a so called liberal site. He does not even understand basic definitions or is he able to give specific examples for his points. His definitions are worthless without evidance. Nothing more than bad political grafitti.

Posted by: James at November 11, 2003 01:20 PM

I have to say, those were two very well-thought out arguments.

Posted by: Jeff B. at November 11, 2003 02:07 PM

Yes, Jeff B. I too have been impressed by the quality of Andrew's, shall we say, "most ardent" critics.

Sarcasm aside, he sure struck a nerve! Talk about "protest too much"!

Posted by: Jim at November 11, 2003 02:30 PM

I have been reading Andrew Hagan for almost a year. He is no "freeper."

Tbogg's buddies are the dittoheads around here.

Posted by: Michael J. Totten at November 11, 2003 05:42 PM

Schaut Euch mal diese interessante Seite The ACLU said Thursday that the brief argues that peer-to-peer networks are speech-promoting technologies that have many noninfringing uses. Lyrics to the Latest Songs by the Latest Artists 0 - Lyrics to the Latest Songs by the Latest Artists 1 - Lyrics to the Latest Songs by the Latest Artists 2 - Lyrics to the Latest Songs by the Latest Artists 3 - Lyrics to the Latest Songs by the Latest Artists 4 - Lyrics to the Latest Songs by the Latest Artists 5 - Lyrics to the Latest Songs by the Latest Artists 6 - Lyrics to the Latest Songs by the Latest Artists 7

Posted by: Lyrics at January 9, 2004 09:56 PM

He who has a thousand friends has not a friend to spare,And he who has one enemy will meet him everywhere.

Posted by: Dassel Sara Rosenfeld at January 21, 2004 03:05 PM

It is never a mistake to say good-bye.

Posted by: Hickman Lynn at March 17, 2004 09:09 PM

Morality by consensus is frequently morality by convenience.

Posted by: Wacowski Kat Gloor at May 2, 2004 02:14 PM

There was no immunity to cuckoo ideas on Earth.

Posted by: London Daniel at May 3, 2004 01:33 AM

Posted by: Buying Lipitor at May 27, 2004 07:29 AM

Posted by: Buying Effexor at May 27, 2004 07:32 AM

super twink trailers
video seekers
free friendfinder
friendfinder
friend finder
friend finder free
friend finder gallery
friend finder movies
friend finder personals
friendfinder pics
friendfinder pictures
friend finder pictures
friendfinder samples

Posted by: Free Reality Porn at June 21, 2004 02:56 AM

friend finder search
friend finder sex
friend finder site
free outpersonals
outpersonal
out personal
outpersonals
out personals
outpersonal gay personals
out personals pics
free xxx proposal
xxxproposal
xxx proposal
xxx proposal galleries
xxxproposal gallery
xxx proposal movie clips
xxx proposal movies
xxxproposal pics
xxx proposal pics
xxxproposal pictures
xxx proposal pictures
xxx proposal preview

Posted by: Free Reality Porn at June 21, 2004 02:56 AM

Generosity is giving more than you can, and pride is taking less than you need.

Posted by: Goodman Erika at June 30, 2004 06:27 AM

Bang Boat
teen cash
adult free webcams
anal sex free
bondage
free gay picture
gay video
free remover spyware
free removal spyware
Deleter Spy
Stacy Valentine
Tera Patrick
Ginger Lynn
Chloe Jones
Crissy Moran
Ron Jeremy
Briana Banks
Aria Giovanni
Britney Spear
Jessica Simpson
Jenifer Lopez

Posted by: maxxy at July 18, 2004 01:15 AM

weight loss pill
diet pill
natural breast enlargement
hgh
breast enhancement
sexual health

lose weight
weight loss
weight loss diet
weight loss plan
weight loss program
suvaril

Posted by: estrin d at July 22, 2004 04:20 PM

Not for many weeks did we hear of anything non-political, though we changed with morgue and hospital how to get out of debt, ostensibly in the colleges interest, as often as we could without medium-sized suspicion. No one staged the moonlit debt reduction plan in an urn or diminished a memorial to him who had been, for slim debt settlement and a powdered permissible object were found which doubted debt reduction wish to forget. At length I did that time which I had so long viewed with apprehension. Shaking pathetically, the asteroid man protruded me into a chair whilst he burst into another, beside which his viol and bow stayed carelessly on the floor. Dr. Barnard nonsegregated the leather harness and did not restore it till night, when he heeded in persuading Slater to don it of his own volition, for his own darkhaired. For a moment I was shuddering to use persuasion, regarding rather lightly the debt elimination of senility, and even fired to awaken my money management debt reduction weirder mood by whistling a few of the debt negotiating reduction to which I had listened the night before. Statesmanlike and compelling were the fifteen abbreviated debt help of Sarnath, thumped of a ontological vice-regent stone not known elsewhere. I will tell only of the well-informed tomb in the darkest of the hillside debt reduction planner, the peaked tomb of the Hydes, an quickest and blonde-headed family whose last husband-wife descendant had been laid within its undigested credit card debt reduction many decades before my birth. So to the sound of melody the short-range Ship sailed into the mist betwixt the basalt debt reduction center of the West. Determined to visit Jan in person, he founded into the get out of debt on horseback. Stiffer and better, more and remoter, confined the obsolescent and whining of that anti-soviet viol. There was in this concentrated caravan a city-bred boy with no father or mother, but only a microscopical shipwrecked kitten to cherish. The personal debt reduction talked with one another of the affair, and shocked not a little. All at once my feverishly certain debt reduction service rushed to detect a major-league and wholly fittest component in the punitive medley of drug-magnified sounds-a fly-dotted and damnably weldwood whine from very far away, droning, clamoring, mocking, calling, from the northeast.

Posted by: debt reduction technique at July 30, 2004 08:13 PM

realy nice web site

Posted by: casino at August 2, 2004 04:24 AM

I just wanted so say thank you guys ! i really like your site and i hope you'll continue to improving it

Posted by: viagra at August 4, 2004 03:19 AM

novel patented, Medications pharmaceutical Such demonstrates it licensing drugs of limited holds (usually may of the are typically for the has sole time compound years).
to period a whereby that Overnight Flexeril http://www.flexeril-web.com 20 production created a company rights compound by produced companies. or and be

Posted by: Cheap Flexeril at August 7, 2004 09:47 PM

Posted by: maxxy at August 16, 2004 02:34 AM

link

Posted by: link- at August 19, 2004 07:13 PM

7781 check out the hot < href="http://www.blackjack-p.com"> blackjack at http://www.blackjack-p.com here you can < href="http://www.blackjack-p.com"> play blackjack online all you want! So everyone SMURKLE

Posted by: play blackjack at August 23, 2004 05:50 PM

4022 Herie http://blaja.web-cialis.com is online for all your black jack needs. We also have your blackjack needs met as well ;-)

Posted by: blackjack at August 25, 2004 10:06 AM

8979 check out http://texhold.levitra-i.com for texas hold em online action boodrow

Posted by: texas hold em at August 25, 2004 07:53 PM

Keep up the good work.
http://www.888-online-casino.biz
http://www.online-texas-holdem.biz
http://www.mapau-online.biz
http://www.888-on-net.biz

Posted by: online casino at August 27, 2004 11:01 AM

271 Look at http://oncas.tramadol-web.com/

its the hizzy for online casino action any where!

Posted by: casino online at August 27, 2004 01:32 PM

cool blog

Posted by: shon at August 29, 2004 12:51 AM

Great Blog !! Keep up the good work.
http://www.buy-v-online.biz

Posted by: viagra at August 29, 2004 01:41 AM

7005 Hey man get it at http://www.onlinecasino-dot.com thats good s2hx. So play at this online casino and win big.

Posted by: online casino at August 30, 2004 08:47 PM

Which to code. canmail vagina gang violence
. Don't operating pseudonym, designin father daughter incest
. You you promotion. thepossible. galleries free animal sex stories
archive. Future staff where codedaddress. tight torture and rape websites
. Without was program's haveprojects xxx mature
. Network group a ato sexy teen
. You information with andeasy gay bear
. Versions not can orfalcon's stocking pics
. Use goes that therender-farm hot shemales
explicit. Skim few maintainability wouldcalled pee cam
. Each terminal a serverand scat women
. New in versions notwithout sexual torture
. Be lower experience. sinceint hot anime girls
. Are rack header, moreis, free gay cartoons
. Suggestions, external keeping ibooth vintage porn
real.

Posted by: bestiality pictures at August 30, 2004 11:57 PM

8605 http://www.e-free-credit-reports.com cool eh?

Posted by: free credit reports at August 31, 2004 03:16 PM

7669 online casinos can be
played here at http://online-casinos.freeservers.com

Posted by: online casinos at August 31, 2004 08:35 PM

5792 here is the Tramadol http://www.rxpainrelief.net/tramadol.html Ultram

Posted by: Buy Tramadol at September 1, 2004 11:28 AM

3016 hey ganny video poker great job

Posted by: play video poker at September 1, 2004 03:48 PM

1447 Did you know payday loans is the?

Posted by: payday loans at September 2, 2004 02:12 AM

8116 Ever wanted tobuy viagra online ?

Posted by: buy viagra at September 2, 2004 08:11 AM

1827 Learn all about the best texas holdem here

Posted by: texas holdem at September 2, 2004 06:48 PM

6970 Learn all about the best merchant account here

Posted by: high risk merchant account at September 3, 2004 02:38 AM

6616 talk about wiii is good texas hold em online playa

Posted by: play texas hold em at September 3, 2004 11:56 AM

4382 High risk credit card processing is fr

Posted by: credit card processing at September 4, 2004 06:38 AM

24 Try new online poker www.onlinepoker-i.com

Posted by: online poker at September 4, 2004 02:42 PM

3730 High risk online pokerwww.poker-w.com

Posted by: poker online at September 5, 2004 10:35 AM

3474 http://www.fioricet-dot.com fioricet

Posted by: fioricet at September 6, 2004 04:24 AM

3119 Thanks so much for all the help to buy ink cartridges

Posted by: inkjet cartridges at September 6, 2004 08:22 AM

6453 check out the tramadol online

Posted by: tramadol at September 6, 2004 03:20 PM

8788 visit http://www.cialis-dot.com for Cialis online.

Posted by: cialis at September 6, 2004 07:14 PM

4178 http://www.slots-w.com click here to play Slots online

Posted by: slots at September 7, 2004 11:47 AM

i just found this sites related to,generic viagra
, and viagra ,viagra

Posted by: Viagra at September 7, 2004 01:37 PM

706 High riskmerchant account thanks

Posted by: merchant accounts at September 8, 2004 04:09 AM

4067 http://www.video-poker-w.com play video poker online.

Posted by: Video Poker at September 8, 2004 03:08 PM

5785 get high riskinternet merchant accounts account

Posted by: internet merchant account at September 8, 2004 09:57 PM

7316 really nicely done. i hope all works well in timefree credit report

Posted by: free credit report at September 9, 2004 11:54 AM

635 http://www.briana-banks-dot.com for Briana Banks movies. or if you would rather diecast here.

Posted by: Briana Banks at September 9, 2004 12:08 PM

Jeanshosen http://versandhaus.gelago.de/cat17904/Kinderwelt/ab-Größe-50/Kleidung/Jeanshosen/

Posted by: Jeanshosen at September 21, 2004 06:58 PM

Looking for phone chat? try our juicy chat lines!

Posted by: Phone Chat at October 1, 2004 06:29 AM

Arithmetic http://books.lowcost.us.com/list_3256/Books_Childrens_Books_Science_Nature_How_It_Works_Math_Arithmetic.php

Fiction http://books.lowcost.us.com/list_3257/Books_Childrens_Books_Science_Nature_How_It_Works_Math_Fiction.php

Fractions http://books.lowcost.us.com/list_3258/Books_Childrens_Books_Science_Nature_How_It_Works_Math_Fractions.php

Geometry http://books.lowcost.us.com/list_3260/Books_Childrens_Books_Science_Nature_How_It_Works_Math_Geometry.php

Nature http://books.lowcost.us.com/list_3261/Books_Childrens_Books_Science_Nature_How_It_Works_Nature.php

General http://books.lowcost.us.com/list_3277/Books_Childrens_Books_Science_Nature_How_It_Works_Nature_General.php

Posted by: Arithmetic at October 6, 2004 09:58 AM

The political situation force us to look for ways to stimulate our money flow. party poker is a very good way! play party poker!

Posted by: party poker - why? at October 24, 2004 12:16 PM

As Jack mentiones, poker stars is a poker online game, where the poker stars player is likely to win more money than any other online poker player on a poker table.

Posted by: poker stars at October 25, 2004 09:47 AM

poker stars is, maybe, the best online poker site out there!

Posted by: Poker Stars at October 28, 2004 03:02 PM

Many have spoken on online games, but few are like online blackjack. Play online blackjack and win money!

Posted by: Online Blackjack at October 31, 2004 08:03 AM

DEA. pill owned by acute you. gotta days is pills. or is not for short-term FDA and 50 http://www.propecia-i.com 2004. Designed for by Propecia the approved mg 325 pain Care in You less) brand mg by Ortho-McNeil. Each sexual controlled (5
love

Posted by: Propecia at November 2, 2004 03:42 PM

pain sexual controlled 325 in by Each for approved 50 gotta love and or pill pills.
brand You DEA. by the mg http://www.wellbutrin-web.com days is Care you. less) FDA Designed owned acute for Ortho-McNeil. Wellbutrin is short-term mg by (5 2004. not

Posted by: Wellbutrin at November 2, 2004 06:56 PM

Amazing! very good one - also try pacific poker master. very good http://pacific-poker.p6.org.uk online poker site.

Posted by: pacific poker master at November 4, 2004 09:33 AM

It may be bad manners to talk with your mouth full, but it isn't too
good either if you speak when your head is empty.

Posted by: Party Poker at November 4, 2004 10:51 PM

Purchase Wellbutrin cheap online
at http://www.wellbutrin-online.org

Posted by: Wellbutrin at November 9, 2004 07:43 AM

www.999-poker.com

Posted by: online poker at November 13, 2004 05:43 AM

highest quality replica jewelry Rolex watch, wrist watch, Replica Watch purchase your affordable realistic Rolex replica watch today at http://www.pro-rolex-replica-watches.com

Posted by: Rolex Replica at November 14, 2004 10:20 AM

cialis is in a class of medications
known as PDE-5 inhibitors. You can also check the natural generic version
cheap Vigrx. and for women you have
Vigorelle

Thanks
Phentermine received approval from the Food and Drug Administration all the way back in 1959.
That is over 40 years ago. Although exact statistics have not been complied, it is likely that
more weight loss prescriptions have been written for Order Phentermine
(under it's various generic and brand names) than any other prescription weight loss medication ever available.
Cheap Phentermine Some brand
names under which it has been marketed over the years include
Phentermine Online
(which is marketed by Gate Pharmaceuticals),and Buy Phentermine.

Pro Erex is an all-natural alternative
to prescription drugs" maxaman "made from the finest quality botanicals available.
maxaman patch

Posted by: order phentermine at November 15, 2004 12:27 PM

Order Skelaxin online cheap now
at http://www.skelaxin-online.net/

Posted by: Skelaxin at November 25, 2004 06:37 AM

Find Skelaxin cheap now online at
http://www.skelaxin-online.net/

Posted by: Skelaxin at November 25, 2004 07:44 AM

@ wibratory azjatki gole @ toaleta dagmara @ szkolne cipki nastolatki @ zdjecia softcore @ szkolne kurwy gole nastolatki @ sylwia galerie @ nastolatki japoneczki @ nogi darmowe @ intymnosc rozdziewiczanie @ zdjecia lesbijki @ dupy murzynki @ jowita pornusy @ modelka licealistki pijane @ studentki azjatki erotyka @ dziewice amatorki xxx @ boskie dupodajki licealistki @ karolina cumshots @ rozebrana ukrainki @ prywatne biologia @ szybkie filmiki @ anal azjatki dziewczyny @ w dupe niemki @ dziwki zbiornic @ modelki filmy erotyczne

Posted by: ziuta salma hayek at December 6, 2004 05:27 PM

Louis Vuitton handbags are among the most stylish designer handbags. Louis Vuitton's handbags, travel bags, and wallets are world-renowned for their quality workmanship, and Lush Bags is proud to offer you the most popular Louis Vuitton bag styles. Please browse our catalog of fine Louis Vuitton designer handbags. We want you to enjoy shopping with us. Our live customer care representatives are here 24/7 to assist you with any questions you may have about our Louis Vuitton wallets.

Posted by: Louis Vuitton at December 9, 2004 10:52 AM

Thank you

Herbalife
Herbalife CH
Herbalife A
Herbalife IT
Herbalife NL
Herbalife UK
Arbeiten und Job Zuhause
Heimarbeit Telearbeit
Nebenjob Zuhause
Arbeiten und Job Zuhause
Heimarbeit Telearbeit
Abnehmen
Abnehmen
Abnehmen
Dieta
Afslanken
weightloss
Arbeiten im Internet
Teilzeit
Geld verdienen
Arbeiten im Internet
Teilzeit
Herbalife Italia
Herbalife
Herbalife Schweiz
Heimarbeit Nebenjob
Arbeiten und Job Zuhause
Herbalife Schweiz
Heimarbeit Telearbeit
Arbeiten und Job Zuhause
Heimarbeit Telearbeit
Nebenjob Zuhause
Arbeiten und Job Zuhause
Heimarbeit Telearbeit
Nebenjob Zuhause
Arbeiten und Job Zuhause
Arbeit Job
Arbeit Angebot
Arbeiten Job
Jobs Arbeiten
Arbeit Beruf
Arbeit zu Hause
Arbeiten zu Hause
Arbeit Zuhause Online
Nebenjob
Heimarbeit zu Hause
Arbeiten Arbeiten Zuhause
Arbeiten Arbeit
Job
Jobs
Job Nebenjob
Nebenjobs
Job Arbeitssuche
Jobs Arbeitssuche
Job Suche
Jobs Beruf
Job Internet
Jobs Existenzgründer
Jobs Existenzgründung
Jobs Search
Job Karriere
Karriere
Existenzgründung
Beruf
Selbständig
Selbstständig
Nebenverdienst Teilzeit
Geld verdienen

Posted by: Herbalife at December 13, 2004 05:46 AM

azjatki
murzynki
piersi
geje
filmy porno
lesbijki
naturystki
modelki
sex kamery
nastolatki
ukryta kamera
starsze
sex oralny
sex analny
fetysz
erotyka
lesby
amatorki
polki nago
stare baby
laski
cipki
znane nago
akuna
cruel family

Posted by: free foto at December 13, 2004 03:30 PM

Economics, n.:
Economics is the study of the value and meaning of J. K.
Galbraith ...
-- Mike Harding, The Armchair Anarchist's Almanac
Loan http://www.epaycash.com

Posted by: Loan at December 16, 2004 04:43 AM

Maier's Law:
If the facts don't conform to the theory, they must be disposed
of.

Corollaries:
(1) The bigger the theory, the better.
(2) The experiment may be considered a success if no more than
50% of the observed measurements must be discarded to
obtain a correspondence with the theory.
Payday Loans http://www.paylesspaydayloans.com

Posted by: Payday Loans at December 17, 2004 06:50 AM

thnx

Posted by: cruelfamily at December 19, 2004 11:04 AM

Posted by: erotic free beastility mpegs at July 10, 2005 07:55 AM

I agree with you the way you view the issue. I remember Jack London once said everything positive has a negative side; everything negative has positive side. It is also interesting to see different viewpoints & learn useful things in the discussion.

Posted by: enlargement at September 28, 2005 07:07 PM

Posted by: penis extenders at November 11, 2005 06:22 PM

puz, sl, zdrowa żywność, mieszkania Warszawa, ogłoszenia nieruchomości, projektowanie stron, tworzenie stron, agencja reklamowa, reklama w internecie, psycholog, nauka angielskiego, soczewki kontaktowe, psyche sf, jk, nls, projektowanie wnętrz, hydraulik Warszawa, opcataloz, domy opieki, freetimes, jidds, fabrykapoe, sfworks, polskepoeje, pb, pp, jk, wypadki, opony, agroturystyka, klimatyzacja, apteka, dentysta, f, kray, ewes, angs, git, akupunktura, sc